Did This Fatal Accident Happen On Orchard Road?

By February 21, 2020 Transport

We were alerted to a 35-second clip of a fatal road accident circulating on Whatsapp.

Explicit videos of road accidents being circulated on messaging platforms and social media are (unfortunately) pretty commonplace, but a watermark on this particular video alleges that this accident happened on 18 February 2020, on Orchard Road towards (‘menuju’) Mount Elizabeth Hospital.

The circulated video is actually footage from a fatal accident that happened in Sochi, Russia in July 2018.

How we uncovered this was through a reverse image search using Tineye, which lead us to this link. We then translated the title of the article to English, and found an article on The Sun which covered the accident.

But even if there was no report on the accident, there are still a few glaring pieces of evidence that prove that this accident likely didn’t happen on that road, let alone in Singapore.

Let’s break it down, step by step.

A: The road markings

The first piece of evidence can be seen from the line of white painted triangles seen on the road.

If they don’t familiar to you, it’s because there are no such road markings used in Singapore! If anything, the only marking vaguely close to painted white triangles on Singapore roads are Traffic Calming Markings (TrCM), introduced in 2009.

As a quick background, the TrCM are white triangular markings painted on the road to create a visually narrower lane that encourages motorists to slow down.

In addition, a broken white line (and not a line of triangles) is used to indicate the edge of a road adjacent to an accelerating lane, according to the Basic Theory of Driving handbook.

B: The speed limit sign

Road signs showing the speed limit in Singapore need to have a 600mm x 600mm square border around the red circle, like this:

The speed limit sign in the video didn’t possess the compulsory square white border.

Given that the sign in the video doesn’t comply with this rule, it’s very likely that the video was not taken in Singapore.

C: The short broken white line

Finally, the short broken white line painted seen in the video is a marking that doesn’t even exist on Singapore roads.

Bonus: The road itself

As a bonus, let’s check if the road mentioned in the video even exists in Singapore.

This is the map view of the point on Orchard Road towards Mount Elizabeth Hospital:

And here it is on street view:

It’s therefore quite clear that the road in the video isn’t the same one that was suggested by the watermark.

Therefore, the claim that this fatal road accident happened in Singapore on Orchard Road towards Mount Elizabeth Hospital on the 18th of February this year is false.

Leave a Reply